The two congeneric hyperiids Themisto libellula and T. abyssorum provide an important trophic link between lower and higher trophic levels in the rapidly changing Arctic marine ecosystem. These amphipods are characterized by distinct hydrographic affinities and are hence anticipated to be impacted differently by environmental changes, with major consequences for the Arctic food web. In this study, we applied DNA metabarcoding to the stomach contents of these Themisto species, to comprehensively reveal their prey spectra at an unprecedented-high-taxonomic-resolution and assess the regional variation in their diet across the Fram Strait. Both species feed on a wide variety of prey but their diet strongly differed in the investigated summer season, showing overlap for only a few prey taxa, such as calanoid copepods. The spatially structured prey field of T. libellula clearly differentiated it from T. abyssorum, of which the diet was mainly dominated by chaetognaths. Our approach also allowed the detection of previously overlooked prey in the diet of T. libellula, such as fish species and gelatinous zooplankton. We discuss the reasons for the differences in prey spectra and which consequences these may have in the light of ongoing environmental changes.